Nov 10, 2012

HR29 in magazines

When making the decision of buying Dolphin Dance (named Johanne then) three years ago, I tried to gather all the information I could find on HR29. I had never sailed the boat, but just visited a couple of them in the harbour. Unfortunately, there was very little information to be found on the magazines. For example none of the Finnish boating magazines had tested this boat. The only article I came across was a short one page article by Yachting Monthly (11/1996).


This YM article is titled "A blend of conservative hull and performance rig". Besides writing about accommodation and general sailing characteristics, the writer wonders the 7/8 fractional rig, which is untypical for an older HR:
"Christoph Rassy and Olle Enderlein appeared guilty of some convoluted thinking; why else would they marry a modern fractional sailplan to a hull which looked tailor-made for a conservative masthead rig? Obviously, with 600 boats built up until 1993, they got the balance right between seakeeping and speed, proving that it's not just flat-bottomed cruiser-racers which can enjoy the benefits of a bendy spar." 
At the time of the design, the 7/8 fractional rig was a modern choice especially for a pure cruising boat. However, today the term 'performance rig' sounds bit of an overstatement, because the sturdy spar in HR29 has equal diameter from root to top whereas modern spars often taper towards the top. This makes them easier to bend. But I very much like the simplicity of the fractional sailplan, and find it more practical than the traditional masthead rig.

Article on Yachting World 

Newly, I discovered that more older articles had been added to the Yachting & Boat World archive. Thus, Yachting World's and Yachting Monthly's old HR29 test articles from 1989 are now also available for download. I decided to buy the YW's five page 'Long test' article, because it would be interesting to read what testers have written about the boat, and compare this to my own experiences.


The YW article (6/1989) acknowledges good sailing characteristics:
"Just because a boat is destined for a cruising lifestyle doesn't mean that it shouldn't be interesting to sail. HR29 certainly keeps the helmsman interested and offers a perceptible response to correct sail trim. "
"Generous sail area offers good light weather performance" 
I agree, that an HR29 is an interesting boat to sail, in all but light winds. However, the boat in the test was equipped for the Round Britain Race and had a modified rig for masthead drifters. In general, the article should be considered in relation to the time when it was written, since boat design has developed quite a lot in the last twenty years - although, not all of the development is positive in my opinion. However, a modern boat of the same size would most probably have greater width, less weight, bigger downwind sail area, flat-bottom, shorter keel and a spade rudder. This will result in better performance especially in light winds and downwind. However, a traditional hull shape has other qualities:
"To cruise comfortably under sail is the raison d'être of the HR29. She panders to no racing rule and, while taking note of modern design trends, is sensibly traditional in almost every way."
Access to engine and quiet installation scored high marks in the test and it is easy to agree with that. However, it is a bit surprising that the boat is said to be "extremely handy" under power. I have found that maneuvering astern in tight quarters is...well, not very handy, especially when compared with  modern boats with shorter fin keel and spade rudder.

In the article, there are some complaints  regarding for example single-clipped hoses, exposed wiring runs attached to bulkheads, the lack of leecloths for the saloon berths and the lack of masthead tricolor light. However, all of these are quite easily fixed afterwards.

If you have an HR29 or you are otherwise interested in this boat, it might be a good idea to check those articles. They can be downloaded from Yachting & Boating World archive.

Feel free to leave a comment if you have experience or questions on this boat! And as always, you can also e-mail us at sydolphindance(a)gmail.com.
/Antti

2 comments:

  1. Having never sailed a HR 29 I can not realy comment. I have however sailed a few Sadler 29's and a HR 26. I think that all that could be said on the HR range of boats and their designe has been said but I will point out one thing. Sailing in the HR 26 was a hell of an experience. I offered to help someonae get from Falmouth to north Spain in a HR26. The owner thought it was but I had different a bit small for the job but I wanted to see how she woould handle the ope sea. SO we headed out 100 miles and then headed south. To keep this short in the 9 days at sea we had winds from F2 to F9. I carried a Jordan Drogue from my yacht for safety and we deployed this for 32 hrs in winds that were gusting to F10 and never had to worry about the yacht. On arrival in Spain the owner said he would get a bit more experience then go for a circumnav. I am afraid I have lost contact with the owner and the last I heard from him he was in Uruguary hin one of the eading south best. NO the best 26 fotter I have ever sailed in. One day I will get the chance to sail in a HR 29 but as I now have bad health (heart) and am 67 Itmay not happen. But we must dream of the day. Cheers good winds and fair seas to you. Pete

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Pete, thanks very much for sharing your interesting story about the HR 26. It must have been quite an experience with a small boat in the Biscay! Fortunately, the boat was up to the task.
    Best wishes from a cold Finland! Antti

    ReplyDelete

It would be very great to hear your opinion or comments. Thank you in advance for commenting! -Antti & Minna